austin_dern (austin_dern) wrote,

Wait a minute, Mister Postman

And now for another first: the first student -- or, really, anyone -- to request a letter of recommendation from me. Fortunately, it was a student I (a) honestly recognized and (b) would be happy to recommend for most anything. And the student did things right, having all the needed information to make it easy -- the proper form (in this case just a plain old text file I could fill in and print out), the deadline (critically important), and the full data on to whom to address it. All I had to do was evaluate the student's scholarly attitude, personality, and likeliness to participate in the cultural opportunities offered by the summer program. I was kind of guessing on the last one.

I recognize the need for and utility of letters of recommendation, but there is an unavoidable barrier between instructor and student; I only see the ``professional'' face. That's a great face in this case and I like the person so far as I've seen, but I did feel a bit dishonest answering the question. I know how the student acts in and around class, and teaches other students, and prepares homeworks. I don't know what the student does for fun, or out of habit, or for fear of failure or for hope of success. But those sorts of doubts are inappropriate for a letter of recommendation, so I'll leave them here instead.

Trivia: Edward Hyde, the Lord Cornbury, 1661-1723, first Royal Governor of the Colony of New Jersey, was the first known recipient of a bribe in what would become the Garden State. The year was 1703; the amount, 100 pounds. Source: Jerseyana: The Underside of New Jersey History, Marc Mappen.

Currently Reading: The Origins and Development of the English Language, Thomas Pyles and John Algeo.


  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.